BECHTEL VS. BOLIVIA : THE PEOPLE WIN!!
By Jim Shultz
The Democracy Center
January 19, 2006
The Cochabamba water revolt -- which began exactly six years ago this month -- will end this morning when Bechtel, one of the world's most powerful corporations, formally abandons its legal effort to take $50 million from the Bolivian people. Bechtel made that demand before a secretive trade court operated by the World Bank, the same institution that coerced Bolivia to privatize the water initially. Faced with protests, barrages of Emails, visits to their homes, and years of damaging press, Bechtel executives finally decided to surrender, walking away with a token payment equal to thirty cents. That retreat sets a huge global precedent.
The Cochabamba Water Revolt
In January 2000 the people of Cochabamba, Bolivia woke up one morning to discover that their public water system had been taken over by a mysterious new private company, Aguas del Tunari. The World Bank had coerced Bolivia to privatize its water, as a condition of further aid. The new company, controlled by Bechtel, the California engineering giant, announced its arrival with a huge overnight increase in local water bills. Water rates leapt by an average of more than fifty percent, and in some cases much higher. Bechtel and its Spanish co-investor, Abengoa, priced water beyond what many families here could afford.
The people demanded that the rate hikes be permanently reversed. The Bolivian government refused. Then the people demanded that the company's contract be canceled. The government sent out police and soldiers to take control of the city and declared a state martial law.
In the face of beatings, of leaders being taken from their houses in the middle of the night, of a seventeen-year-old boy being shot and killed by the army -- in the face of it all, the people did not back down. In April of 2000 Bechtel's company was forced to leave and the people won back control of their water.
Bechtel Fights Back
Eighteen months later Bechtel and Abengoa sought revenge, filing a $50 million legal action against Bolivia in the World Bank's trade court -- the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID). It was a legal forum tailor-made for Bechtel. The people of Cochabamba would be tried in Washington, in English, and in a process so secret that no member of the public or press would be allowed to know when the tribunal met, who testified before it, or what they said.
Bechtel claimed it was suing for both its losses and the profits it wasn't allowed to make. Records would later show that Bechtel and its associates had spent less than $1 million in Bolivia.
The People vs. Bechtel
What Bechtel did not count on was the firestorm of public protest that it would face. Cochabamba water revolt leaders, The Democracy Center, and a host of allies all over the world launched a global campaign to force Bechtel to drop the case.
Thousands sent Emails to corporate executives. Protesters in San Francisco blocked the entrance to Bechtel's headquarters, occupied its lobby, and draped a banner across its front. Dutch activists mounted a ladder and posted a sign renaming Bechtel's Amsterdam office after Victor Hugo Daza, the 17-year-old killed in Cochabamba. The San Francisco Board of Supervisors approved a resolution calling on Bechtel to drop its case.
More than 300 organizations from 43 countries joined in a citizens petition to the World Bank demanding that the case be opened to public scrutiny and participation. Activists in Washington DC protested at the home of the head of Bechtel's water company. Hundreds of articles and dozens of documentaries were published and produced worldwide, making Bechtel and its Bolivian water takeover a poster child of corporate greed and abuse.
Bechtel -- a corporation so powerful that it won a billion-dollar, no-bid Bush administration contract to rebuild Iraq -- found it all more than even it could take. Last June, Bechtel and its associates raised the white flag and began negotiating a deal to drop their case -- for a token payment of two bolivianos (thirty cents). Sources close to the negotiations say that Bechtel's CEO, Riley Bechtel, personally intervened to bring the case to and end, weary of the ongoing damage to the corporation's reputation. Bechtel officials flew to Bolivia this week to sign the surrender and collect their two coins.
Bechtel's Surrender -- What it Means
Bechtel's surrender settlement is historic. The World Bank's system of closed-door trade courts has received more than 200 cases like Bechtel's. The WTO and NAFTA trade courts have their own pile of corporate cases. In no other, however, has a major corporation backed down as a result of public pressure.
The public victory over Bechtel is a direct hit against the ever-tightening spider web of global trade rules. International financial institutions, such as the World Bank and International Monetary Fund, coerce poor countries into privatization arrangements as a condition of aid. Corrupt and incompetent governments sit down behind closed doors with multinational corporations and cut bad deals. A year later, or a decade later, the people finally realize what has happened. They demand a reversal and the companies warn, "Mess with the deal and we will take you to court -- and we will win."
In Cochabamba, people "messed with the deal" big time. They took back their water. The global campaign against Bechtel sends an important message to other corporations who are thinking of following in their legal footsteps, in Bolivia and beyond:
"No, we will not let you wage this fight behind closed doors where only a handful of lawyers has a voice. We will wage this fight on your doorstep. We will make you defend your actions in the court of world public opinion, before your neighbors, your friends, and the media."
One thing that corporations know how to do well is math. When Bechtel and its associates did the math on Cochabamba they concluded that the cost to the company's public reputation was greater than whatever payment they hoped to take from the pockets of Bolivia's poor.
One again, it is clear that the economic rules of the game can be changed. Six years ago the people of Cochabamba won their revolt over water with courage and commitment. Today we have all won the water revolt's second and final round, with a persistence that was truly global and that could not be stopped. Another world is indeed possible.
A note: For more information on the Cochabamba Water Revolt visit The Democracy Center's Web site section dedicated to it: http://democracyctr.org/bechtel/
THE DEMOCRACY CENTER ON-LINE is an electronic publication of The Democracy Center, distributed on an occasional basis to more than 3,200 organizations, policy makers, journalists and others, throughout the US and worldwide. Please consider forwarding it along to those who might be interested. People can request to be added to the distribution list by sending an Email to: firstname.lastname@example.org Newspapers and periodicals interested in reprinting or excerpting material in the newsletter should contact The Democracy Center at email@example.com Suggestions and comments are welcome. Past issues are available on The Democracy Center Web site.
THE DEMOCRACY CENTER SAN FRANCISCO : P.O. Box 22157 San Francisco, CA 94122
BOLIVIA : Casilla 5283, Cochabamba, Bolivia
TEL: (415) 564-4767
FAX: (978) 383-1269